Zanzibar's Shadows and Echoes: The Enduring Impact of the Indian Ocean and Arab Slave Trades

In the heart of the turquoise waters of the Indian Ocean, the archipelago of Zanzibar has stood as a testament to the convergence of cultures and epochs. Its sandy beaches, exuberant spice markets, and azure seas capture the essence of an island paradise. Yet, beyond this tropical allure lies a poignant history, woven with threads of human triumph and tragedy, indelibly marked by the Indian Ocean, Arab Slave Trade and modern day neocolonialism.

Zanzibar: A Crucial Junction in the Slave Trade Network

Commencing from the 7th century, the Indian Ocean and Arab Slave Trade formed one of the most extensive networks of human trafficking the world has ever known. Lasting nearly thirteen centuries, it predated the European Trans-Atlantic slave trade by 700 years and continued long after its abolition.

Zanzibar emerged as a focal point in this reprehensible trade due to its strategic geographical location off the coast of East Afraka, making it a bridge between the Afrakan mainland, the Middle East, and the Far East. According to the historian, Abdul Sheriff, author of "Slaves, Spices & Ivory in Zanzibar," by the 19th century, up to 50,000 slaves were passing annually through Zanzibar's infamous market, overseen by the Sultan of Oman, who had relocated his base from Muscat to Zanzibar in 1832.

Prison Island: A Silent Witness to Horrors Unspoken

A mere 5.6 kilometers northwest of Zanzibar, Prison Island, or Changuu, holds a chilling tale within its serene confines. Ironically, the island never hosted a prison, contrary to its misleading moniker. Instead, it was a holding center for enslaved persons, detaining them before they were sold in Zanzibar's markets. Tales and records from the era reveal the harrowing conditions endured by the slaves. Crammed into tiny, airless chambers, they awaited their fate, branded and sold like commodities. The weak or sick were discarded without a second thought. Even today, the dilapidated structures on the island whisper tales of the inhumanity endured by its captives.

Unraveling the Impact of the Slave Trade on Zanzibar

Despite the abolition of the slave trade in Zanzibar by the British in 1873, the echoes of this past reverberate through time. The slave trade drastically shaped Zanzibar's social, cultural, and economic landscapes, molding its history and shaping its present. A prominent legacy of the slave trade is the formation of the Afro-Arab community, a fusion of the Arab traders and indigenous Afrakans. Over time, intermarriages between the two communities gave rise to a distinct group, contributing to the multicultural mosaic that characterizes Zanzibar's population today. Elements of this synthesis are evident in the local Swahili language, a blend of Bantu languages with heavy Arabic influences. However, the transition from a slave-driven economy to a 'free' one was not without its complications. After the cessation of the slave trade, the Zanzibari economy pivoted towards spice cultivation, particularly cloves. Today, Zanzibar is known as the 'Spice Island,' its spice tours attracting visitors from across the globe. But beneath this flavorful success lies a bitter truth – the same hands that were enslaved to cultivate spices now work in precarious conditions, often struggling to make ends meet.

Income inequality is rampant in Zanzibar. According to the World Bank's Tanzania Mainland Poverty Assessment, the poverty rate in Zanzibar stood at around 30.4% in 2021, indicating a significant section of the population living below the poverty line. The foundations of these disparities trace back to the socioeconomic structures established during the era of the slave trade. Moreover, the shadow of this dark era extends into the realm of social consciousness. The trauma and collective memory of slavery have seeped into the societal fabric, influencing the narratives of identity, social status, and racial divisions within the Zanzibari society. Yet, this memory is selectively addressed – the slave trade's history is notably absent from the local curriculum, creating an alarming void in the younger generations' understanding of their past.

From First Glance

An undeniable, yet disconcerting trend revealed itself during my sojourn to Zanzibar — an escalating influx of foreign settlers, predominantly hailing from Europe. Spellbound by the island's charming blend of pristine beaches and pulsating local culture, these newcomers often secure land rights, either through purchasing or leasing from the government. The acquired lands invariably become platforms for prosperous businesses, primarily targeting the tourism sector. While, at first glance, this may appear to stimulate foreign investment and stoke the embers of local economic activity, the reality is more complex, and disquietingly less rosy. Beneath this veneer of prosperity lies a stinging truth — the deep-rooted economic inequity that not only enables such transactions to persist but also marginalizes the local community.

With the entry of foreign businesses, local markets are often skewed, inflating prices beyond the reach of average residents. This burgeoning tourism economy, rather than integrating the local populace, increasingly seems to segregate them, pushing them further to the periphery. The economic landscape, instead of becoming a tool for local upliftment, morphs into a mirror, reflecting the profound socio-economic chasm that continues to widen within Zanzibar's society. It's a stark reminder that the prosperity of a few often casts long shadows, obscuring the plights of the many.

This "phenomenon" in Zanzibar, I noticed, is disconcertingly reminiscent of divisions seen elsewhere on the African continent, particularly the historical segregation that blighted South Africa. The most glaring manifestation of this is the rise of what are colloquially termed as "Mzungu" schools. These institutions, predominantly occupied by white students, seem to mirror the structures of apartheid-era Bantu education, yet in this context, the separation is less explicit and more insidious. The exclusivity of these Mzungu schools lies not in legal segregation, but in an economic division. The elevated tuition fees act as a gatekeeper, systematically denying access to most of Zanzibar's local populace who cannot afford them. While not overtly discriminatory, this de facto segregation fosters an environment of division that is difficult to overlook.

The emergence of these demarcated educational spaces showcases a worrying dynamic, bearing uncomfortable parallels to racially divided societies. In these microcosms of education, a world of economic disparity is played out in miniature – a sharp division that underlines the privileges accorded to one section of the populace at the expense of the other. While the advent of foreign investment brings a promise of economic growth and increased opportunities, the reality is that it often deepens existing inequities. It shapes an environment where the rich get richer, and the poor, left to wrestle with an escalating cost of living, become even more marginalized. This situation presents a stark juxtaposition against the backdrop of Zanzibar's historical struggle against the forces of slavery and colonialism. It underscores the pressing need for a reevaluation of current economic policies, in order to ensure that growth and development benefit all segments of the society, not just a privileged few. The heritage of Zanzibar and the resilience of its people demand no less.

On the one hand, these foreign enterprises can stimulate the local economy, generate employment, and expose locals to global market dynamics. On the other hand, this increased foreign presence drives up the cost of living and can create a market dynamic where essential goods and services become inaccessible to many Zanzibaris. This phenomenon, often termed as ‘economic gentrification,’ presents a challenge to achieving inclusive growth and shared prosperity on the island. There is also a risk that this modern wave of foreign influence could inadvertently contribute to a new form of neocolonialism. The unequal distribution of wealth, power, and resources between Zanzibaris and their foreign counterparts could perpetuate global equity gaps and deepen local social disparities. The echoes of Zanzibar's past, once characterized by forced labor and exploitation, are eerily reminiscent in this new context of economic imbalance.

Prison Island Today: Conservation and Remembrance

Today, Prison Island is more commonly known for its giant Aldabra tortoises, a species native to Seychelles. Gifted to the island by the British governor of Seychelles in the late 19th century, these tortoises have found a sanctuary here. The transformation of the island into a nature reserve signifies an attempt to reclaim a painful past and transform it into a symbol of conservation and life. Yet, the remnants of its historical function as a slave holding center – the haunting ruins and dilapidated structures – serve as a potent reminder of the human suffering the island once witnessed. They now stand as silent monuments, whispering stories of the past to those who come seeking Zanzibar's history.

Looking Forward: Healing and Reconciliation

Zanzibar, while carrying the weight of its historical past, is looking towards a future of reconciliation and healing. The first step towards this is acknowledging the full scale of the impact of the slave trade. Educational reforms to include this crucial chapter of Zanzibari history in school curriculums, raising awareness through public commemorations, and investing in the welfare of the marginalized sections of society are essential steps towards this goal. Despite the atrocities of the past, Zanzibar's history is a testimony to human resilience. The island is a testament to the strength of the human spirit and its ability to rise from the ashes of adversity, presenting a model of endurance, resilience, and reconciliation for the world.

The history of Zanzibar is intricately linked with the Indian Ocean and Arab Slave Trade, a narrative that has influenced its social, cultural, and economic landscapes. As we walk the streets of Stone Town, breathe in the aroma of the spice markets, or gaze at the tranquil waters surrounding Prison Island, we must remember the echoes of a bygone era that still resonate in these spaces. For it is in remembering that we can ensure that history does not repeat itself, and we can aspire towards a future rooted in equity, justice, and respect for all. The island's development and economic equity dynamics continue to be shaped by international forces, much like its past. An understanding of Zanzibar's history, culture, and societal structure can offer valuable insight into the complexities of its present situation. Despite the trials and tribulations, Zanzibar has weathered, it continues to hold a certain allure, standing as a poignant reminder of human resilience and tenacity. It is a testament to a global community's capability to learn from the past, adapt to the present, and aspire for a more equitable future. Although the global community must become aware of the modern-day struggles - economic gentrification, neo-colonial tendencies, and persistent social disparities - that bear testament to its past. As Zanzibar navigates this intricate socio-economic terrain, it serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring impacts of historical events on present realities. Despite the bitter shadows of the past and the challenges of the present, Zanzibar embodies the spirit of resilience - a compelling narrative of an island persistently striving for progress.

The struggle continues.

References

1. Akou, H. M. (2011). The politics of dress in Somali culture.

2. Alpers, E. A. (2009). East Africa and the Indian Ocean. Markus Wiener Publishers.

3. Bhacker, M. Reda. (1992). Trade and Empire in Muscat and Zanzibar: Roots of British Domination. Routledge.

4. Campbell, G. (2007). Abolition and its aftermath in the Indian Ocean, Africa and Asia. Routledge.

5. Chittick, N. (1974). Kilwa: An Islamic Trading City on the East African Coast.

6. Clarence-Smith, W. (2013). The Economics of the Indian Ocean Slave Trade in the Nineteenth Century.

7. Glassman, J. (1995). Feasts and Riot: Revelry, Rebellion, and Popular Consciousness on the Swahili Coast, 1856–1888.

8. Lofchie, M. F. (1965). Zanzibar: Background to Revolution.

9. Lyndon, J. (2013). Zanzibar: The Hundred Days Revolution. Zed Books.

10. Middleton, J. (1992). The World of the Swahili: An African Mercantile Civilization.

11. Rizvi, H. (2016). Plantation to postcolonial: Postcolonial views of history, slavery, and rural capitalist development in Zanzibar, 1830–1914.

12. Sheriff, A. (1987). Slaves, Spices & Ivory in Zanzibar: Integration of an East African Commercial Empire into the World Economy, 1770-1873. James Currey.

13. The World Bank. (2019). Tanzania Mainland Poverty Assessment. The World Bank.

14. Ylvisaker, M. (1982). Miners, Merchants, and Warriors in the African Borderland: Colonel D.H. Edwards' Life and Letters from the Gold Coast.

Taken in Paje, Zanzibar